Review
Gemini
A well-regulated exchange carrying a hard-earned trust problem
Our Verdict
On paper Gemini is buttoned-up: it is SOC 2 certified, regulated by New York (NYDFS), and its custody is insured - all signals that the exchange itself is run carefully. But Gemini Earn changed the story. When Genesis, the lender behind the program, went bankrupt, Earn customers lost access to their funds. In February 2024 NYDFS said more than 200,000 customers were still unable to access their virtual currency, and that Gemini had committed to return at least $1.1 billion to them through the Genesis bankruptcy. In our view, that cost Gemini a good deal of the trust it had spent years building. If you can look past Earn, the exchange underneath is solid. Our verdict: many people understandably cannot look past it.
What we like
- SOC 2 Type II certified - strongest compliance certification in the industry
- NYDFS-regulated trust company (not just a money transmitter)
- Insurance on hot wallet assets
- Gemini ActiveTrader has competitive fees (0.2-0.4%)
- Clean, well-designed interface
- Winklevoss twins are visible, accountable founders
What could be better
- Gemini Earn: customers lost access to funds when Genesis, the program's lender, went bankrupt (NYDFS said over 200,000 were affected as of February 2024)
- Community trust fell after Earn, based on the r/Gemini and r/Bitcoin threads we read
- Convenience fee on simple trades (see Gemini's fee schedule)
- Multi-coin exchange - altcoin promotion in the app
- Smaller trading volume than Coinbase or Kraken
- Gemini credit card rewards program scaled back
How We Scored This
Community score compiled from Reddit threads, expert reviews, and app store ratings.
The Gemini subreddit has many threads from Earn customers about access to funds and recoveries.
r/Bitcoin threads discuss Gemini's Earn program alongside its exchange security and regulation.
Gemini maintains SOC 2 Type II certification and is regulated as a New York trust company.
Genesis Global Capital filed for Chapter 11 in January 2023. Gemini Earn users were creditors. In February 2024 the New York Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) announced that Gemini Trust Company, LLC would pay a $37 million fine, which NYDFS tied to Gemini failing to conduct due diligence on an unregulated third party, and would commit to return at least $1.1 billion to Earn customers through the Genesis bankruptcy. The release says that, at that date, over 200,000 Earn customers remained unable to access their virtual currency, and that Gemini committed to work through the bankruptcy process toward a full recovery for them. The episode demonstrated that "regulated" does not mean "safe from counterparty risk."
4.3/5 on the App Store, but reviewers mention the interface and security, and some discuss Earn.
Score History
Published aggregated community review. Community score (10/25) reflects the trust damage from the Gemini Earn / Genesis bankruptcy.
Related Reviews
Explore more Bitcoin product reviews
Newsletter
Bitcoin insights, no noise.
Bitcoin explained without the hype. Updates when they matter.